Welcome back to The Society Dispatch. Let's get into it.
In 1961, the year Adolf Eichmann went on trial in Jerusalem for his role in the Holocaust, a psychologist at Yale named Stanley Milgram started wondering about the same question Hannah Arendt was writing about from the courtroom.
How do ordinary people end up doing terrible things?
Milgram designed an experiment. Participants came in believing they were testing whether punishment helped learning. A researcher in a white lab coat sat in the room. A learner was strapped to a chair in the next room. Every time the learner got an answer wrong, the participant was asked to administer an electric shock, increasing in intensity each time.
The shocks weren't real. The learner was an actor. The screams were recorded.
But the participants didn't know that. And 65 percent of them administered the maximum shock of 450 volts, well past the point where the actor had gone completely silent.
They didn't want to do it. They were visibly distressed. They asked if they could stop. But when the researcher in the white coat said "the experiment requires that you continue," most of them continued.
This wasn't a study about cruelty. It was a study about authority. The white coat was doing most of the work.
We are wired to comply with perceived authority in ways that bypass our own judgment. It doesn't have to be a government or an institution. It can be a uniform, a title, a confident tone, or simply the presumption that the person asking knows what they're doing.
Napoleon understood this deeply. He didn't just want to win battles. He wanted to look inevitable. He designed his own coronation, his own symbols, his own mythology. He understood that authority, once perceived, almost runs itself.
The uncomfortable question Milgram's experiment leaves us with isn't "could I be manipulated by authority?" Most of us could. The useful question is: whose authority are you currently complying with, and have you ever actually examined why?
Not all authority is illegitimate. But unexamined authority is always a liability.
This week: Pick one belief or habit you follow because someone in authority told you to. It could be a boss, a parent, a system you work inside. Ask: do I actually agree with this, or am I just complying? You don't have to act on the answer. Just notice it.
Until next week. Study people. They're fascinating.
Gabrielle
Founder, The Persuasion Society
Not subscribed yet? Join free at thepersuasionsociety.com